Art Shapiro, distinguished professor of evolution and ecology, has been studying the butterfly populations of Central California for 48 years. So, when Kathy Keatley Garvey, communications specialist in the Department of Entomology and Nematology, sought an expert to comment on the effect of recent wildfires on butterflies, she naturally turned to him. He wrote the following, which first appeared on Garvey’s Bug Squad blog Oct. 13.
Rising from the Ashes — Some Day
People ask me all the time where butterflies go when it rains. Now they’re asking me where they go when it burns.
In a word, to the Elysian Fields. They have nowhere else to go!
The unprecedented wildfires have destroyed very important butterfly habitats in 2020, particularly in the High North Coast Range where a million acres — mostly in the Mendocino National Forest — have burned.
We have been doing biogeographical survey of the butterfly faunas of this region beginning in 1974. Earlier fires largely removed the fir forest from the upper reaches of Snow Mountain (summit 7,056 feet), leaving it covered in successional montane chaparral. But Goat Mountain (6,112 feet), Hull Mountain (6,831 feet), Anthony Peak (6,958 feet) and Black Butte/Mendocino Pass (7,455 feet) still had many intact plant communities containing rare and relict species (many of which were isolated and far removed from their core ranges in the Sierra Nevada and/or the Klamath Mountains).
These included very rare wet meadows (as at Plaskett Meadows near Mendocino Pass) and treeless “balds” on rocky summits, usually facing southwest, producing a simulacrum of alpine fell-fields typically found several thousand feet higher.
Some species may be gone for good
We had documented roughly 115 species of butterflies in these places. Some, like the Nevada Arctic (Oeneis nevadensis) and the Arctic Skipper (Carterocephalus palaemon) were at their southernmost range limits, not just in the Coast Ranges, but globally.
One butterfly new to science, the Bald Hills Satyr (Cercyonis incognita), was discovered at mid-elevation on Goat Mountain (100 percent of which burned) and in a few spots farther north. All of its known habitats may have burned — we won’t know until we can get in, not before next year — and it is possible that it is extinct.
In addition, we discovered that the widespread, familiar Pine White (Neophasia menapia) was apparently two sibling species on Goat Mountain and near Seven Troughs Spring in the Mendo Pass area, flying several weeks apart and with morphological differences. We did publish that one! All the known localities for the late-season entity have burned, too. This situation is of special interest because the idea that species could originate through temporal isolation has been discussed for many decades, but rarely if ever firmly documented. (The classic case, in field crickets, has been falsified by DNA analysis.) We have to be thankful that we got the data we did before the holocaust. Now, of course, the pressure is on to digest it.
Habitats must recover first
Recovery of the butterfly faunas cannot occur until the vegetation resources they depend on come back — and they may never do so. Glacial relics, like the unique four-petaled Plaskett-Snow Basin race of the bog shooting-star Dodecatheon jeffreyi — personally, I think it deserves species status — may never come back. Nor many of the stranded alpine and edaphic (soil-specialist) species, because they are so far from any conceivable seed source. We have to hope they have persisted in the soil seed bank and may in time recover. Only then can the butterflies re-establish — if there are sources of potential colonizers.
The farther any unburned sources and the weaker the dispersal capabilities of the butterflies, the longer the lag times to recolonization. Only the most vagile and broadly-adapted species are likely to recolonize a burned area of a million acres anytime in the next half-century or more.
The fires of 2020 were fed by the combination of 60 percent of recent mean precipitation in the 2019-20 rainfall year and extraordinary evapotranspiration demand on the vegetation resulting from the hottest late summer on record. Yes, climate change is real. And our Coast Ranges butterfly faunas may never be the same again.